LOVE THE BOOK, BUT POST DISAPPOINTMENTS HERE

[Guest]

Subscribe RSS Reader 

[Holly]

But remember that in the tent when Edward and Jacob were talking Edward told Jacob that he was so jealous that he could barely control his voice..and they almost got into a fight when Jacob squished Bella waking up - if she hadn't stopped them I bet they would have gotten into it! But maybe it's better - since they became friends in BD.

[Claire]

Good point Holly!  Isn't it funny how we can go on for hours about the emotions and actions of fictional characters?! 

But remember that in the tent when Edward and Jacob were talking Edward told Jacob that he was so jealous that he could barely control his voice..and they almost got into a fight when Jacob squished Bella waking up - if she hadn't stopped them I bet they would have gotten into it! But maybe it's better - since they became friends in BD.

[JoanneD]

Ok, I'm with you guys on the fight scene too.

But my other disappointment is about the way Bella's attitude was toward Edward...especially when he was proposing!  Hello, millions of ladies would do anything to be in your position and you're not happy!  My heart was so sad for Edward!!!

Oh I know, I felt so bad for him. Like I get it that she has a thing about marriage and whatever, but if you're willing to spend eternity with someone marriage seems like a very small request.. poor Edward, like he had to make it a condition in order for her to accept, it shouldn't have to be that way.

[EclipsedMe]

I was disapointed when Bella kissed Jacob and Edward didn't fight him, he didn't even felt hurt by her. In my opinion Edward was too civilized, he should have turned his back on her untill she begged for him to return. But I undestand he's feeling guilty about leaving her during "new moon"... She really doesn't deserve him, or Jacob.

[JuliaHale]

Eclipse was great, my only disappointment was that Jacob and Bella kissed twice, and one time, Bella liked it. UGH!